Coolest Places to Get Your Cone On in Saranac Lake

It’s time to talk about ice cream, and I couldn't be happier. It’s summertime, it’s hot, and every single night I crave ICE CREAM. This isn’t ideal for my waistline, and I need to invest in a gym membership, but my taste buds are satisfied.

Being the nice person that I am, I took one for the team by sampling five tasty treats at some of the best ice cream stands in the area. All I can say is YUM!

 Stop #1: The Cone Cabin (Lake Clear)

First stop: The Cone Cabin!

Newly opened this year, the Cone Cabin is serving up tasty food and even tastier ice cream. The cabin offers a flavor of the week, and when I went with my friend, Mary, it was pistachio. I have a nut allergy, so Mary was kind enough to try it for me. A little baby cone was the perfect bite. I tried the chocolate and vanilla twist with rainbow sprinkles, of course — I’m all about the sprinkles. This is a great spot to stop during a camping trip at Fish Creek, after a day on the course at Saranac Inn, or a day on the lake paddling or boating!

 A taste of pistachio and sprinkles!

Stop #2: Donnelly’s Ice Cream (Saranac Lake)

A long line is a common sight at Donnelly's.

An Adirondack staple, the specialty here is a classic twisted cone. Donnelly’s Ice Cream is proclaimed “the best in the Adirondacks since 1953” when it comes to ice cream. Their classic flavors are twisted with vanilla, and the schedule is as follows: 

Monday: Nut Surprise

Tuesday: Red/Black Raspberry

Wednesday: Chocolate

Thursday: Fruit Surprise 

Friday: Strawberry 

Saturday/Sunday: Chocolate 

I was there on a Friday recently and had the Strawberry, which is one of my favorites. A few days later the flavor was a peanut butter and chocolate twist special. As you can imagine, the lines were long! My nut allergy got in the way here too, but I heard it was amazing! 

 Two more satisfied customers!

 Stop #3: Teddy’s Ice Cream (Bloomingdale)

My return to Teddy's was a good one.

Teddy’s was built 12 years ago by my aunt and uncle, so I spent many years twisting a cone there. Now under new management, they are offering up homemade, inventive treats to satisfy your sweet tooth.

On Sundays they offer a Sunday Super Sundae. In honor of the Fourth of July last week it had strawberries, vanilla ice cream, homemade red velvet cup cake, homemade blueberry compote, whipped cream, blueberry syrup drizzle, and a cherry on top, and they sold out! They even offer sundae sauces for grown ups like Pina Colada, Bourbon Maple Caramel, and Kahlua Dark Chocolate! Um…yum!

Besides ice cream, Teddy's also has homemade lemonades and iced teas to quench your thirst on a hot day, or wash down the delicious food they’ve been whipping up! 

Who can resist?

Stop #4: Mountain Mist Custard (Saranac Lake)

Mountain Mist, where summer memories come in a cone!

I remember going to Mountain Mist as a child, and looking forward to ice cream and sitting out back to watch the boats go by and see the ducks. Sometimes I would get an M&M Chozen Frozen just like my mom, which is simply M&M’s churned together with vanilla ice cream, but I loved it. My standby was a simple vanilla cone with rainbow sprinkles. You really can’t go wrong with anything you get there. It’s definitely kid approved! They also offer food and ice cream cakes! 

Great ice cream with a view!

Stop #5: The Pine Cone (Ray Brook) 

The Pine Cone is a popular roadside stop.

The Pine Cone is family owned and opened in 2013, and has been an ever-growing spot since then. Their silky smooth ice cream is the perfect treat for a hot summer night. If you’re looking for something different than a traditional cone, try one of their homemade chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwiches! Or try some dirt on your ice cream — thinly crushed Oreo cookies that make an awesome topping! It sounds weird but it tastes great! Bring your furry friends too because they get a free doggie cone! 

Fun for the whole family!

And there you have it — some of the best ice cream to indulge in while you are visiting Saranac Lake this summer! Plan your stay, and check out all of the events and activities going on to work off all that ice cream (and make sure you have a comfortable bed to go back to after for a nap).

This week's ADK scoop:

Totally twisted

We’ve got all day 

Chillin’ Whiteface style

Drive-in, dive in, delve in

Sweet Schroon

Frost along the shore 

Twisted Tupper 

Author:Brooke O'Neil
Categories:Summer, Family fun, Dining
Coolest Adirondack Chopped Challenge!
A Rainy Day Birding Trip in Madawaska

E-Newsletter Signup Form

About The Author

Blog Topics...

Upcoming Events

Monday, January 22nd, 2018
Micro-Monday  Mini Pitcher special all day on our craft centric draft lineup.  14 draft lines to choose from - with the pitchers starting at $6 and up! Join us!
Monday, January 22nd, 2018
The Village Board meets on the second and fourth Monday of each month with additional meetings scheduled as needed. Meetings take place in the Village Board room, 2nd floor, 39 Main Street...
Tuesday, January 23rd, 2018
The upcoming date less then 1 day.
The weekly meeting for the Rotary Club of Saranac Lake at the Left Bank Cafe. Please feel free to contact us if you're interested in learning more about Rotary.
Tuesday, January 23rd, 2018
The upcoming date less then 1 day.
2fer Tuesday at Grizle T's Every Tuesday starting at 9pm we offer 2 for 1 draft, bottle, and canned beer, well liquor, champagne, and wine!  See you there!

Recent Blog Posts...

Tuesday, January 23rd, 2018
As I got ready for my thrift shop expedition, my husband cautioned me, "Now don't go crazy." I don't know why he is always asking this of me. I consider my enjoyments to be springing from...
Tuesday, January 16th, 2018
If a game of King of the Hill that ends in tears and a handful of snow down your collar is your typical day of winter-family-fun — let me help you out! Saranac Lake is bursting...
Tuesday, January 9th, 2018
As I stroll through the village of Saranac Lake, a virtual Norman Rockwell or Currier & Ives painting, I keep waiting for the horse-drawn sleigh to pass by — the passengers in stocking caps and...
Tuesday, January 2nd, 2018
Monitoring the snow depth The beginning of ski season is often a game of figuring out how much snow depth we have and how much snow coverage is needed to explore certain trails. So early season...
Fly to Saranac Lake via Cape Air The Adirondack Regional Airport, your "Gateway to the Adirondacks," provides quick and convenient access to and from Logan International in Boston, MA. Daily flights are provided...
Woods and Water Defined by nature, recreation, heritage, learning, creativity, and cuisine, we invite you to explore our historic routes and waterway connections.
Sign up for our weekly newsletter.
Interested In
Sign Me Up!