Carl Ballantine, comedy magic

The complex of buildings at the edge of Saranac Lake is known as "Will Rogers," since that was the name for much of its history. But it started in 1929 as the National Vaudeville Artists' Home; a tuberculosis curing facility for people in show business.

It was a future destination for a tall young magician. He bounded onto the stage in New York City. Before he could begin his act, he felt a wave of nausea, and collapsed. Instead of dazzling the expectant crowd, he wound up in the "actors sanitarium" in Saranac Lake, with his doctors saying they would know more about his condition in six months. He felt that was an ominous pronouncement.

He may have been a funny guy, but what he was facing now was deadly serious. 

shifting a dream

Carl Ballantine is credited with perfecting the comedy magic concept. Like so many inspirations, it was born of necessity.

He had loved magic since he was nine and the local barber distracted kids with simple tricks. Born Meyer Kessler in Chicago in 1917, he ran through several names including Count Marakoff, Carlton Sharpe, and Carl Sharp while working as a straight magician during the Great Depression. But it was a source of frustration to him that he was not as polished in his magic abilities as many of his competitors.

he began as a serious magician, in the waning days of vaudeville

According to his daughter, he made a joke when a trick failed, loved the audience laughter, and began turning his lack of ability into a true comic act. From then on, he was careful not to call it a magic act, or himself a magician. He was now a comic.

He renamed himself Carl Ballantine, after a bottle of whiskey he saw, and would often add, "I was almost Jack Daniels!" His new act would be "Ballantine, the World's Greatest Magician."

He was eager to pick up his career where he'd left it... as soon as he got better. Curing his tuberculosis would take three years.

it began as the National Vaudeville Artists' Home in 1929

But he did not give up his comic ways. When his six months went by, he greeted the doctors with, "Looks like I'll be sticking around a while more. And so I've been meaning to tell you, the food here is terrible!"

Carl Ballantine was a comic natural. Mel Brooks was to call him “the funniest man on earth.”  While he had developed his act partly out of frustration at not being as good at magic as he wanted to be, magicians like David Copperfield, and comedians like Steve Martin, revered him and cited him as inspiration.

Much of his career momentum had been lost by the time he was able to leave the sanitarium. Three years is a long time in show business.

getting back on stage

There were a few fortunate things Carl had going for him, besides the very fact of his survival. One was that his care had been provided free of charge.

As of 1935, the National Vaudeville Artists' Home became part of the Will Rogers Memorial Commission. The popular entertainer's death in a plane crash had led to the creation of a charitable foundation, partly funded by taking up collections before the movies played in theaters. This widened elibigility to all entertainers, vaudeville or not. A year later, the complex became the Will Rogers Memorial Hospital.

When Carl was declared able to take on the rigors of the road again, he'd had a captive audience for all this time.

donation appeals were once part of the pre-movie show in Depression-era theaters

Carl wasted no time in getting back to rebuilding his career. He'd put together his first act by the time he was thirteen, and now he started again, doing well enough by 1940 to become the first magician to headline in Las Vegas, appearing on a bill with such well-known stars as Harry James, Betty Grable, and Sammy Davis Jr.

Now he was on a roll again. Always impeccably dressed, he would appear on stage in a top hat and tails.

whether the emphasis was on comedy or magic, he always kept the traditional formal dress

"If the act dies, I'm dressed for it," he'd say. One popular staple would be him tearing a newspaper into strips, claiming he would restore the paper. "But just in case," he would add, "let's check the want ads."

He began to become a common sight on television. Variety shows were hugely popular then. "I was on Sullivan a lot," he remembered. "But Sullivan would never get the jokes."

a genuine star

Those variety show spots began to pay off. He became nationally famous with his character, Torpedoman's Mate Lester Gruber, on the "McHale's Navy" television show that aired from 1962 through 1966.

he became famous with his character, Lester, on McHale's Navy

In this highly popular show, Carl played a con artist from Brooklyn, who used his magic skills and street smarts to get the other members of the crew in, and then out, of trouble. He would reprise the role in the first "McHale's Navy" movie, along with castmates Ernest Borgnine and Tim Conway. 

This led to more comedic acting roles in the movies, such as "The Shakiest Gun in the West" (1968), "The World's Greatest Lover" (1977), and Billy Crystal’s directorial debut, "Mr. Saturday Night" (1992). His last feature film role was in "Aimee Semple McPherson," a 2006 biopic about the female evangelist.

He was a staple on television during this era, from magician “Al Henderson,” working the 53rd precinct Christmas Party for brother-in-law Officer Toody in episode 15 of the 1st season of "Car 54, Where Are You?" in 1961 to a 1973 TV movie, "The Girl Most Likely to..." with Stockard Channing. 

In his later years, he got work as a voice artist, first in "Freakazoid!" (1995) as Huska, then in "Garfield and Friends" (1988) as the devious Al G. Swindler.

While working on "Speedway" (1968), Elvis Presley wanted to give him a Cadillac. But his wife, actress and cabaret singer Ceil Cabot, wouldn't let him accept it. He was also a devoted family man, even if he did name their two daughters after racetracks: Saratoga, the actress, after the racetrack in New York, and Molly Caliente, after a track in Tijuana. 

his constant comic patter was part of his personality, on stage, and off

In 2007, he received the 2006 "Lifetime Achievement Fellowship from the Academy of Magical Arts." Carl Ballantine would live to the age of 92, wisecracking and playing the ponies, almost to the end. His last performance had been the year before, the "It's Magic" show at the Kodak Theatre in Hollywood.

Will Rogers lives on. It's now Saranac Village at Will Rogers, an extraordinary place for independent retirement living, with interesting talks, monthly outings, and other cultural events. Show business, after all, is in its bones.

Carl Ballantine's legacy lives on in the performers he inspired. And what a delight it is.

Start that trip to Saranac Lake with the right lodging. Indulge in some delightful dining. Explore our incredible history.

Photo acknowledgements: Will Rogers ad courtesy of Historic Saranac Lake wiki website. Early magician photo from Skirball Cultural Center. Formal and autographed photos from katzizkidz. Picture quote from AZ Quotes.

In related Fame In The ADKs news:

Dewey’ing it with decimals.

The Adirondack hermit.

A star-studded past with more stars on the horizon.

Lighting the way for the rich and famous.

Meadowmount: Multiple strings attached.

Wheeler goes to Washington.

Synonymous with opera, art, and the silver screen.

Categories:Arts, Heritage, Wellness
Love among the cure cottages
Saranac Lake Arts Beacon

E-Newsletter Signup Form

About The Author

Pamela Merritt's picture
Pamela Merritt finds a library's reading room as exciting as a hike through the forest. She met the Adirondacks in 1999 and declared it "home." She's been collecting stories ever since. She declares summer's hiking and kayaking blends beautifully into winter's snowshoeing and reading to create four great seasons of enjoyment. Her published works display her eclectic range, from How-To cat care manuals to literary short fiction.

Blog Topics...

Upcoming Events

Friday, November 22nd, 2019
The upcoming date less then 1 day.
Dewey Mtn XC Ski and Snowshoe Swap Here’s how it works!! Friday, November 22nd from 5:00PM to 7:00PM Dewey Mountain will be open and accepting Cross County Skis, Snowshoes, and ski clothing...
Saturday, November 23rd, 2019
To event remaining 1 day
Dewey Mtn XC Ski and Snowshoe Swap Here’s how it works!! Friday, November 22nd from 5:00PM to 7:00PM Dewey Mountain will be open and accepting Cross County Skis, Snowshoes, and ski clothing...

Recent Blog Posts...

Wednesday, November 13th, 2019
If a game of King of the Hill that ends in tears and a handful of snow down your collar is your typical day of winter family fun — let me help you out! Saranac Lake is...
Thursday, October 24th, 2019
In Saranac Lake, we love our history. From the region's earliest inhabitants — the Iroquois people who hunted here — through the first 19th century settlers to the development of the village as a...
Earn Your Patch There’s an adventurous spirit in all of us. In Saranac Lake, you can answer that call by becoming a Saranac Lake 6er.
Unplug Outdoors The mountains, rivers, and lakes bordering Saranac Lake aren’t just for show, and those boots on everyone’s feet aren’t a bold new fashion statement.
Enter to Win Sample Saranac Lake with this getaway package. Enter now!
Sign up for our weekly newsletter.
Interested In
Sign Me Up!